ProQuest www.csa.com
 
About CSA Products Support & Training News and Events Contact Us
 
RefWorks
  
Discovery Guides Areas
>
>
>
>
>
 
  
e-Journal

 

Hygiene in the Industrial World:
An Unhealthy Obsession with Cleanliness?

(Released June 2011 2011)

podcast link 
 
  by Kathryn Mori & Carolyn Scearce  

Review

Key Citations

Visuals

News

Glossary


Editor
 

Human Health and the Problem of Uncertain

Contents

In the context of modern medical research, it is often difficult to determine the best choices for protecting the health and well being of ourselves and our loved ones. As in the case of the hygiene hypothesis, we are frequently presented with tantalizing glimpses into the factors potentially affecting human health but offered no definitive answers. Ultimately, the current state of medical knowledge does not offer irrefutable proof regarding which versions, if any, of the various sub-hypotheses associated with the hygiene hypothesis give the most accurate information regarding how to protect and maintain human health.

There are many difficulties regarding epidemiological studies that make it difficult to identify the ultimate causes of human diseases or other factors impacting human physiology. There are a number of reasons that this is so. For one thing, many diseases can be affected by a variety of genetic and environmental factors. Also, it is extremely difficult to perform controlled studies on human populations. Human subjects may submit to health studies, but they are frequently short in duration and limited in the scope of factors that they can account for. For practical, ethical, and behavioral reasons, it is impossible to control or even completely identify the multitude of everyday factors that influence an individual’s state of health.

The results of a survey of asthma prevalence in the U.S
The results of a survey of asthma prevalence in the U.S. from the National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Epidemiologists rely heavily on tools such as questionnaires, which are not always completely accurate. When people are questioned about their medical histories they may not remember correctly, or purposely conceal information they feel uncomfortable revealing. Also, epidemiology relies heavily on statistics. Statistics may be good at revealing correlations between multiple data sets, but correlation does not always point clearly to causality. For instance, Strachan's initial study for the hygiene hypothesis was able to uncover a correlation between increased incidents of allergies in smaller families but the cause of this relationship was a matter of speculation. As the original hygiene hypothesis suggests, insanitary contact between children may help strengthen a child's immune system. However, it is also possible that the size of the family is merely related to some other factor in modern lifestyle that actually leads to increased allergy rates.       
 
Given the current state of uncertainty regarding the hygiene hypothesis and its multitude of variations, no individual course of action seems readily available to best optimize human health. In fact, some versions of the hygiene hypothesis suggest that the best means of decreasing inflammatory conditions is by exposing young children to dangerous bacterial and viral infections or by exposing adults or children to intense parasitic infections. If such is the case, it may be that the cure is potentially worse than the disease. Should further research convincingly demonstrate such extreme measures are necessary to treat these conditions, it may be medically expedient to follow such a course of action for extreme suffers. However, such therapies would require very close medical supervision to manage the risks involved. Since such extreme measures have yet to be shown to provide the best course of action, it is unlikely that many physicians would be inclined to advocate or even monitor such potentially risky courses of action.

On the other hand, the hope of promoting a more positive state of health is associated with some of the more moderate versions of the hygiene hypothesis. If it is true that the immune system can be primed by a consortium of non-pathogenic bacteria, then fairly simple and much less risky changes in behavior may be able to do much to decrease the incidence of inflammatory disorders. It may be that choices such as being less preoccupied with sterilizing the objects that infants come in contact with or making sure that young children come in frequent contact with other children of a similar age may improve overall health later in life. Other factors such as encouraging children to play outdoors or introducing them to healthy domesticated animals may also be beneficial. Additional factors could involve being vigilant in ensuring that people are not given unnecessary antibiotics and promoting less refined diets that are rich in prebiotics and probiotics.          

There is no certainty that these changes in behavior will prevent a person from developing allergies, or even reducing the severity of allergies. Even if these are the factors that are associated with the development of allergies, epidemiology addresses statistical trends and not how a single person will respond to individual genetic, environmental, or lifestyle factors. Even in undeveloped countries there are some people who still show allergy symptoms. There is still a lot to be learned about allergies and other inflammatory conditions and how individual biological factors influence the level of incidence. The high rate of variation of allergies from one country to another does suggest that environmental and/or lifestyle choices may have a significant impact on the frequency and intensity of allergies. However, there also seems to be a significant genetic component, and for a segment of the population, allergies may currently be unavoidable.

© 2011, ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

List of Visuals

References
  1. "Achievements in Public Health, 1900-1999: Healthier Mothers and Babies." Morbity and Mortality Weekly Report, 48.32 (1999):849-858. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4838a2.htm>

  2. "Asthma cases increase sixfold in 30 years in Japan." Medical News Today. MediLexicon International Ltd., 30 Sept. 2004. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/releases/14222.php>

  3. Bloomfield, S., R. Stanwell-Smith, R. Crevel, and J. Pickup. "Too clean, or not too clean: the Hygiene Hypothesis and home hygiene." Clinical and Experimental Allergy, 36 (2006): 402-425. Print.

  4. "Charter Oath." Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Encyclopædia Britannica, 2011. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/107679/Charter-Oath>

  5. Corsini, Carlo and Pier Viazzo, eds. "The Decline of Infant Mortality in Europe—1800—1950–Four National Case Studies." Florence: UNICEF, 1993. PDF file. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/hisper_decline_infantmortality.pdf>

  6. Douglas, Laurelyn. "Health and Hygiene in the Nineteenth Century." The Victorian Web. The Victorian Web, 1991. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.victorianweb.org/science/health/health10.html>

  7. Efron, Sonni. "Cleaning Up on Hygiene Mania." Los Angeles Times 21 Nov. 1996. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://articles.latimes.com/1996-11-21/news/mn-1397_1_cleaning-hygiene-antibacterial>

  8. Engels, Friedrich. The Condition of the Working-Class in England in 1844. Trans. Florence Kelley Wischnewetzky. 1892. Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, 2005. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.gutenberg.org/catalog/world/readfile?fk_files=1507671&pageno=1>

  9. Faria, Miguel. "Medical History—Hygiene and Sanitation." Medical Sentinel 7.4 (2002): 122-123. Print.

  10. Gilchrist, Mary, Christina Greko, David Wallinga, George Beran, David Riley, and Peter Thorne. "The Potential Role of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations in Infectious Disease Epidemics and Antibiotic Resistance." Environmental Health Perspectives 115.2 (2007): 313-316. Print.

  11. Graff, Amy. "Do day-care kids have stronger immune systems?" SFGate. San Francisco Chronicle, 27 Jan. 2009. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/blogs/sfmoms/detail?entry_id=34916>

  12. Gutierrez, David. "Antibiotics used in meat pose a threat to public health, admits FDA." Natural News.com. Natural News Network, 22 Oct. 2010. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.naturalnews.com/030132_antibiotics_meat.html>

  13. Halling-Sorensen, B., H.-C. Holten Lutzhoft, H. Andersen, and F. Ingerslev. "Environmental risk assessment of antibiotics: Comparison of mecillinam, trimethoprim and ciprofloxacin." Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy 46.S1 (2000): 53-58. Print.

  14. Hanifin, Jon and Michael Reed. "A Population-Based Survey of Eczema Prevalence in the United States: Methods." Dermatitis 18.2 (2007): 82-91. Print.

  15. "Helicopter Moms vs. Free-Range Kids." Newsweek. Newsweek, 21 Apr. 2008. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://www.newsweek.com/2008/04/20/helicopter-moms-vs-free-range-kids.html>

  16. "Joseph Lister." historylearningsite.co.uk. History Learning Site, n.d. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/joseph_lister.htm>

  17. Koloski, Natasha, Laurel Bret, and Graham Radford-Smith. "Hygiene hypothesis in inflammatory bowel disease: A critical review of the literature." World Journal of Gastroenterology 14.2 (2008): 165-173. Print.

  18. Larson, Elaine, Susan Lin, Cabilia Gomez-Pichardo, and Phyllis Della-Latta. "Effect of Antibacterial Home Cleaning and Handwashing Products on Infectious Disease Symptoms." Annals of Internal Medicine 140.5 (2004): 321-329. Print.

  19. Lee, Jong-Chan. "Modernity of Hygiene in the Megiji Era, 1868-1905 – Moralizing Imperial Bodies." Research Group of the History of Health and Healing, n.d. PDF file. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://www.ihp.sinica.edu.tw/~medicine/ashm/lectures/Lee%20Jong-Chan-ft.pdf>

  20. Levy, Stuart. "Antibacterial Household Products: Cause for Concern." Suppl. of Emerging Infectious Diseases 7.3 (2001): 512-515. Print.

  21. Manuel, Laura. "Bring on the Germs. A Call to End the ‘No-Sickness-Allowed’ Culture." Tortoise on the Loose. WordPress.com, 20 Mar. 2010. Web. 1 Jun. 2011. <http://tortoiseontheloose.wordpress.com/2010/03/20/bring-on-the-germs-a-call-to-end-a-%E2%80%98no-sickness-allowed%E2%80%99-culture/>

  22. Martinez, Fernando. "The coming-of-age of the hygiene hypothesis." Respiratory Research 2 (2001): 129-132. Print.

  23. Meropol, Sharon, Zhen Chen and Joshua Metlay. "Reduced antibiotic prescribing for acute respiratory infections in adults and children." British Journal of Family Practice 59.567 (2009): e321-e328. Print.

  24. Montgomery, Maggie and Menachem Elimelech. "Water and Sanitation in Developing Countries: Including Health in the Equation." Environmental Science & Technology 41 (2007): 17-24. Print.

  25. Noymer, Andrew. "Life expectancy in the USA, 1900-98." Some Information on TB and the 1914 Flu. University of California-Berkeley, n.d. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://demog.berkeley.edu/~andrew/1918/>

  26. Noverr, M., and G. Huffnagle. "The 'microflora hypothesis' of allergic diseases." Clinical & Experimental Allergy 35 (2005): 1511-1520. Print.

  27. Richards, Evelyn. "In Japan, ATMs Clean Up; Sanitized, Ironed Yen Dispensed for the Fastidious." Washington Post 17 Nov. 1994: a.01. ProQuest. Web. 2 Jun. 2011.

  28. Rook, Graham. "Review series on helminths, immune modulation and the hygiene hypothesis: The broder implications of the hygiene hypothesis." Immunology 126 (2008): 3-11. Print.

  29. Salvi, Sundeep and Stephen Holgate. "Is there a link between hygiene and allergic disorders?" Microbiology Today 28 (2001): 175-177. Print.

  30. Shepherd, Tory. "Hygiene hypothesis: let children eat dirt." The Punch. News Unlimited, 12 Jun. 2010. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://www.thepunch.com.au/articles/a-dirty-piece-on-cleanliness/asc/>

  31. Smith, David, Anthony Harris, Judith Johnson, Ellen Silbergeld, and J. Glenn Morris, Jr. "Animal antibiotic use has an early but important impact on the emergence of antibiotic resistance in human commensal bacteria." PNAS 99.9 (2002): 6434-6439. Print.

  32. Strachan, David. "Hay fever, hygiene, and household size." BMJ 299 (1989): 1259-1260. Print.

  33. Suk, Sarah. "Get ready for a really bad hay fever season this spring." The Japanese Times Online. The Japanese Times, 27 Jan. 2011.Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://search.japantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin/nn20110127f1.html>

  34. Terlisner, Amy. "Eating Worms May Inhibit Allergies, Asthma and Autoimmune Disease." Naturopathic Doctor News & Review Apr. 2008: 12. Aletris Center of Integrative Medicine. PDF file. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://www.aletriscenter.com/allergies_asthma_autoimmune_disease.pdf>

  35. Uranaka, Taiga. "Parasitologist says excess hygiene threatens Japan." The Japanese Times Online. The Japanese Times, 4 Feb. 2001. Web 2 Jun. 2011. <http://search.japantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin/nn20010204a2.html>

  36. United States. Army. Manual of Military Training. 2nd ed. U.S. Army, 1917. WWW Virtual Library. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://www.vlib.us/medical/manual/manual1.htm>

  37. van Wijk, Christine and Tineke Murre. Motivating Better Hygiene Behaviour: Importance for Public Health Mechanisms of Change. New York: UNICEF, n.d. PDF file. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://www.unicef.org/wash/files/behav.pdf>

  38. Warner, John, Michael Kaliner, Carlos Crisci, Sergio Del Giacco, Anthony Frew, Liu Gh, Jorge Maspero, Hee-Bom Moon, Takemasa Nakagawa, Paul C. Potter, Lanny J. Rosenwasser, Anand B. Singh, Erkka Valovirta, and Paul van Cauwenberge. "Allergy Practice Worldwide: A Report by the World Allergy Organization Specialty and Training Council." Allergy & Clinical Immunology International 18.4 (2006): 4-10. Print.

  39. Watanabe, Chisaki. "Japanese parents opt for parks with security cameras and no-germ sand." The Seattle Times 9 Sept. 2006: n.p. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2003250449_scaredparents09.html>

  40. Weber, David and William Rutala. "Use of Germicides in the Home and the Healthcare Setting: Is There a Relationship Between Germicide Use and Antibiotic Resistance?" Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 27.10 (2006): 1107-1119. Print.

  41. Weissman, Susan. "5 Second Rule – Are Germs Good for Your Kid?" Shine. Yahoo!, 9 Sept. 2010. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://astrology.yahoo.com/channel/parenting/5-second-rule-are-germs-good-for-your-kid-2388934>

  42. The World Factbook. United States. Central Intelligence Agency, 2011. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/>

  43. Worm Therapy: Helminth Induced Immune Modulation. Worm Therapy, n.d. Web. 2 Jun. 2011. <http://www.wormtherapy.com/theory.html>

  44. Wright, Jim, Stephen Gundry, and Ronan Conroy. "Household drinking water in developing countries: a systematic review of microbiological contamination between source and point-of-use." Tropical Medicine and International Health 9.1 (2004): 106-117. Print.

  45. Yazdanbakhsh, Maria, Peter Kremsner, and Ronald van Ree. "Allergy, Parasites, and the Hygiene Hypothesis." Science. 296 (2002): 490-494. Print.